About Us Contact Us Help




California School Text Issues: Students Debate With Prof. Michael Witzel At Harvard University

Special Correspondent

On Friday, Feb. 3rd, the Dharma Club, Harvard's Hindu students' organization, held a public forum to discuss the controversy over recent attempts to correct the presentation of Hinduism in textbooks in California. The forum featured presentations by two speakers. The first was Prof. Michael Witzel, Wales Professor of Sanskrit at Harvard, who opposes many of the corrections of the contents on Ancient India proposed for the CA textbooks. The other speaker was Krishna Maheshwari, a student at the Harvard Business School and co-founder of the Cornell chapter of Hindu Students Council (HSC). While Mr. Maheshwari is not a member of either the Vedic Foundation (VF) or the Hindu Education Foundation (HEF), he agrees with the bulk of the proposed changes and volunteered to speak in favor of the corrections at this forum.

Prof. Witzel began by outlining his reasons for opposing the specific corrections proposed by the VF and HEF. He stated that while he understood the Hindu community's concerns about the often negative portrayal of Hinduism in textbooks, he and his supporters felt that many of the proposed corrections were historically inaccurate and thus should not be accepted by the California Department of Education. The Professor attempted to question the motivations of the VF and HEF. He alleged that these organizations have links to groups having Hindu fundamentalist leanings in India. Mr Maheshwari pointed out that Prof. Witzel's attempt in connecting the CA textbook issue of coverage of Ancient India to the current political situation in India is completely uncalled for.


Mr Maheshwari in his presentation eloquently brought out the issues with the textbooks, not just California textbooks, but books from all states. His statement that textbooks are wrong was agreed to by Michael Witzel. He shared his experience in the classroom while he was growing up. Few members from the audience also shared their experiences suggesting that correcting the textbooks is a necessity and is largely agreed upon.

Mr. Maheshwari responded to Prof. Witzel's call for historical accuracy by pointing out that the positions adopted by the VF and HEF are supported by archaeological and genetic evidence and pointed to arguments presented by some of Prof. Witzel's colleagues at Harvard. Mr. Maheshwari also pointed out that due to the complexity of Sanskrit, there are many plausible interpretations of the Vedas and other scriptures concerning issues such as caste and the role of women. The issue in California is about the fair, just and appropriate treatment of Hinduism.  He repeatedly asserted that the presentation of Hinduism should be on par with that of Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.  Mr. Maheshwari also responded to Prof. Witzel's allegations of links between the VF/HEF and Hindu fundamentalism by pointing out that one of Prof Witzel's supporters, Steven Farmer, tried to enlist the support of Christian fundamentalists and other anti-Hindu elements to block the efforts of the Hindu community to change the textbooks; just as it would be unfair to attack Prof. Witzel’s motives because of the activities of his supporters, Mr. Maheshwari argued, it is equally wrong to try to dismiss the VF's and HEF's edits by questioning their motives.

Mr. Maheshwari agreed with Prof. Witzel that in general, it can be difficult to find a balance between sensitivity to religion and historical accuracy.  He pointed out, however, that it is fairly straight forward in the case of elementary school textbooks because the state of California has very clear guidelines for how this issue should be resolved. For example, the guidelines state that no religion can be portrayed as inferior to any other, that no religion can be portrayed as an improvement on another religion, and that the curriculum should instill pride in his or her religion in each student. The fundamental problem in California, said Mr. Maheshwari, is that the guidelines are both not followed and not enforced in the case of Hinduism. Some of the texts trivialize Hindu beliefs, such as one book that tells students to look around for monkeys when discussing the Ramayana. Extensive space is devoted to presenting Hindu theology in terms of social problems such as caste while little space is devoted to actual Hindu philosophy or any achievements of Hindu civilization in areas such as mathematics and medicine. Finally, many books treat problems such as caste and gender discrimination as part of Hindu theology, whereas the Crusades, the Inquisition, and jihad are portrayed as historical events that may not reflect the beliefs of American Christians or Muslims.

Prof. Witzels’s motive in getting involved in the textbooks issue was questioned in the meeting. One person from the audience asked if he read the edits submitted by Hindu groups and also the textbooks before sending the letter to the board citing ‘it may ead to an international educational scandal’. Prof. Witzel refused to answer it citing that the matter was in court. It is not known however, if there is any court case. Another comment came from the audience that though his letter to the CBE on Harvard letterhead listed about 50 signatories as ‘world specialists on ancient India', many of them are not in academics, and majority of them are linguists, non-Hindus and many of them have nothing to do with Hinduism or Indian history. In addition, few historians listed are also questionable, including some with Marxists affiliations. Prof. Witzel had no comments.

Overall, the audience seemed very interested in hearing both sides of the debate. There was general agreement among all present, including Prof. Witzel, that there are serious problems with the way in which Hinduism is presented in American textbooks. However, it is clear that even after this forum, there is still considerable debate within the Harvard community about how the issue should be addressed. There is still a considerable disconnect between the two sides on this issue. Prof. Witzel and his supporters continue to focus on narrowly defined notions of historical accuracy which itself is under considerable debate in academic circles, while the VF, HEF and their supporters are concerned primarily with the ensuring that California state Government's guidelines are followed. It is also expected that just and fair representation of Hinduism and ancient India is ensured in all school textbooks.

Bookmark and Share | Share your Comments

Comments :
Post a new message
1.KedleksNodsda July 13, 2013 
2.NsvNVzgnccmX July 7, 2013Ellen 
3.JmdiuEcpPsyXmNUt July 5, 2013Jayvee 
4.SDXcAHwgKJ June 28, 2013Jodecy 
5.RociTDblMi June 20, 2013Jacki 
6.LSzjgUtZFlHI June 18, 2013Allayna 
7.pPDSMBqykzO June 10, 2013Cherry 
8.gWTUNKQKvjWwUTPKUzR June 4, 2013Kalyn 
9.VyGecRrkaZjoPuGIX June 1, 2013Livia 
10.dUDlHEqlRnZUV June 1, 2013Alex 
11.kNBpLbpWELSdynlU June 1, 2013BertieorBirdie 
12.FKccaTreLxo May 29, 2013Nevea 
13.DZbILYXhYMvnjspO May 26, 2013Emeline 
14.laWotNjtkPv May 13, 2013Koyie 
15.GZuygjRzTQSOcKjH May 10, 2013Becky 
16.GZuygjRzTQSOcKjH May 10, 2013Becky 
17.uZuZbPRcchsK May 6, 2013Addy 
18.jQqYMhZoGhA May 6, 2013Trix 
19.ndjmDiWSlUEXEJeQ April 27, 2013Andralyn 
20.EaqUjdqnjuKQhuXrnCg April 21, 2013Johnavon 
21.aMaYqUCfXEbINZ April 21, 2013Jonni 
22.QJLWpcelDXNwLrAayyb April 21, 2013Karik 
23.uMTLVOGUJUVmlXf April 18, 2013Sanne 
24.YeYcbtMsnnAuUXU April 18, 2013Dortha 
25.GVdWccUfMPo April 17, 2013Voncile 
26.DSUHjWmfGX April 6, 2013Yamary 
27.lHEYwwVgeX March 27, 2013Marilee 
28.TWmitpwhtfXTHCYHWW March 23, 2013Jonnie 
29.PeJbAygaRNDceSOt March 20, 2013Chubby 
30.GAqSsqrCvFLmVBEXV March 12, 2013Candy 
31.JsXLVWTdUdTybmBBi March 6, 2013Jayce 
32.cPWsRnMqlpavr February 24, 2013Eloise 
33.dItguvqlSukDFmdCLIF February 19, 2013Christy 
34.TkLSZKFFtX December 26, 2012Kaylan 
35.eLJSxbyxXae December 22, 2012Jannika 
36.hEdPQimDCgRrqyWO December 16, 2012Lucka 
37.uHnTOwcHmn December 12, 2012Sherry 
38.MhXgfJWIudvPgCzjpeC December 11, 2012Pokey 
39.tvvJNKAIfRMIxneXKb December 4, 2012Flip 
40.XezJwzkVPomKqVwA December 3, 2012Ebony 
41.iQvsWtByuYqMCfWe November 29, 2012Essence 
42.dXwYttwdUNXXFPw November 25, 2012Nikki 
43.zOfljDkamdzchIgmnyS November 21, 2012Cayle 
44.lQHykglEkAhDnAtlw November 13, 2012Alexavia 
45.vGFeMkuPuR November 11, 2012Kelli 
46.WjyjvEdsHrD November 9, 2012Tasmine 
47.otooUwwzfzWlpItF November 7, 2012Nevea 
48.teYKvgYsToQmP November 5, 2012Margaretta 
49.BovCDBvCDH November 1, 2012Margery 
50.cvmMqPXCgAQlOE October 28, 2012Holland 
51.qdYoqRfRxDN October 24, 2012Vinny 
52.uHytTEMCLLMUS October 20, 2012Ryne 
53.UvhkVzOLPfewZXmSg October 19, 2012Betti 
54.cNZxPnSqrLhjcDeQz September 23, 2012Hester 
55.FsetsNWguVU September 6, 2012Carlos 
56.UShIhkpIAOmu September 4, 2012Sevgin 
57.Religious site July 30, 2008simone 

You may also access this article through our web-site http://www.lokvani.com/

Home | About Us | Contact Us | Copyrights Help