Gold often draws attention during times of uncertainty. Headlines will hype its price surges. Critics will warn that it doesn’t generate income. For a wealthy investor balancing retirement, income, tax, and legacy planning, it’s important to understand what gold can and cannot realistically do in a diversified strategy. Here are five things to keep in mind when considering gold’s position in your portfolio.

1: Gold is Not a Scam—But it is Not Magic

Gold’s intrinsic value is based on centuries of use as currency, jewelry, and a reserve asset for central banks. It has consistently provided positive returns and can help safeguard wealth over time. Since 1971, gold has generated long-term annualized returns similar to those of major assets, earning it a place in some institutional portfolios.

Indeed, gold doesn’t generate income. It doesn’t distribute dividends like equities or interest like bonds. Returns depend entirely on price appreciation, and prices can be unpredictable.

2: Gold Can Diversify But Won’t Replace Core Growth Assets

Gold’s low correlation with stocks and bonds is one of its most cited strengths. When equities and fixed income fall together, gold’s price movements usually differ. This can help reduce portfolio volatility and soften drawdowns when markets sell off (meaning less loss during bad markets).

Research from the World Gold Council (WGC) shows that even modest gold allocations (2-10% of a portfolio) have historically improved risk-adjusted returns for diversified investors.

That said, gold should be complementary rather than core to a long-term growth strategy. It can help reduce overall portfolio volatility in small doses over time. Stocks, real estate, and other income-producing assets historically deliver higher long-term total returns, even if they’re more unstable in the short run.

3: Gold’s Price Can Be Volatile in the Short Term

The price of gold has rallied sharply at times, resulting in dramatic year-end gains and record highs. For instance, investors often exchange stocks and bonds for gold when they expect interest rates to fall or when geopolitical tensions arise. 

Conversely, that same metal can drop in value significantly, sometimes suffering drawdowns that exceed those of stocks and bonds over certain periods. Recent strategist commentary highlights that gold has experienced deep downturns (as low as 70% at times) and it effectively hedged inflation only about half the time over long, multi-decade horizons.

This means short-term gold investing can be unpredictable, a reason many advisors emphasize long horizons and modest allocations rather than heavy trading.

4: Taxes and Costs Can Reduce Net Returns

Gold’s appeal as a hard asset carries tax implications that differ from stocks and bonds. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) classifies physical gold as a collectible, which can subject long-term gains to a higher maximum capital gains rate (up to 28%) than the typical 20% rate for equities and mutual funds.

Physical gold also incurs storage and insurance costs. While modern alternatives such as gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or digital gold platforms eliminate vaulting expenses, their management fees and trading spreads can erode returns.

These cost implications are especially meaningful for high-income investors who are focused on efficient legacy planning.

5: Align Type and Allocation With Goals

Gold investment types vary. Physical assets, including bullion, coins, and bars, have storage, liquidity, and pricing nuances. Gold ETFs offer ease of trading and institutional custody but represent paper claims on metal rather than direct control or ownership. Other options include gold mining stocks, which bring operational equity-like risks.

Financial advisors suggest keeping gold allocations modest (typically well under 10% of portfolio total) to add diversification without overshadowing income-producing and growth assets. An investor’s goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon determine how gold should function, whether in a diversification or hedge capacity.

How Gold Fits Into a Holistic Investment Framework

Gold can be an effective tool in a well-balanced, goal-oriented plan. It doesn’t replace earnings, dividends, or yield. It doesn’t solve retirement spending needs on its own. Instead, its strengths lie in potentially smoothing portfolio volatility over long horizons, offering a non-correlated asset that may help protect purchasing power during market stress or currency weakness.

For affluent investors with complex tax, retirement, and legacy planning goals, every asset should be evaluated through a consistent framework that weighs growth potential, income generation, risk, liquidity, and tax efficiency. Gold deserves consideration on its merits and limitations—not based on hype or fear.

|